Most Reliable Pc's 2010

Can we disobey the laws? The future

The advantage of this issue is being raised from a very distant past - with Antigone, for example - and ask ourselves today, where web laws will turn into delinquents countless downloaders of the Net.

The downside was that we like being trapped by failure to respond affirmatively to a law which could be disobeyed with impunity would no longer be one.

The law in effect, unlike the rule, admits of no exception, and no can not be above the law, except to be within the realm of nature, that is to say the balance of power: the "law" of the jungle.

Then: Antigone Creon is a rebel that would be right to punish, whatever the Gods?

Obviously not: for Antigone claims to be a law - the law of God - who wants his brother's funeral, and that law is above the law of the city defended by Creon.

-> 1 st idea: there is a hierarchy of laws: laws must be consistent them, and when two statutes are in conflict, one that is greater legitimacy than outweighs the lower. We can disobey it if it is the condition to obey that.

remains to be seen how the upper and lower what is?

remains particularly whether there are cases where all laws are on the same plane, thus implying that one can not disobey the law by claiming a greater legitimacy.

-> 2 nd idea : All legislators claim to be unique, and when this is not the case, they take the system of higher laws as a preamble to their constitution. So are all plans that do not lay with the laws of God, so do we do with the Declaration of Human Rights .

As these laws are well defined and codified, there is normally no problem.

... Except that the problem is still: in the interpretation of the facts, and therefore the application of the law.

-> 3 rd idea: we can try to prove you do not disobey the laws, despite appearances.

downloaders See the Net: they do not shout "Down with private property! . They simply say that their practices do not despoil the artists as they would in any case not purchased their registration with the price. They only correct an injustice - as Robin Hood, they just steal the robbers.